How Google Indexing Works (And What Can Go Wrong)

Imagine you’ve written a brilliant book—your ultimate guide to digital marketing. Now, you take it to the biggest library in the world, hoping people will find it. If the library doesn't catalog it correctly (or at all), that book might as well not exist.

In the digital world, Google indexing is that cataloging process. It’s the final, crucial step that makes your website’s pages searchable. If your page isn't in the Google index, it won't appear in the search results, no matter how great your content is. This is a common, silent killer of SEO efforts, and knowing what can go wrong is the key to ensuring your content gets seen.

At Social Geek, a digital marketing agency located in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, we specialize in technical SEO, and we've helped countless clients troubleshoot these exact problems. We turn "missing" pages into high-ranking assets. Let's dive into the core mechanics of how Google works and how to guarantee your spot in the Google search index.

Understanding The Difference Between Crawling And Indexing

Many people use "crawling" and "indexing" interchangeably, but they are two distinct and sequential processes in how Google discovers and ranks your content.

1. Crawling (The Discovery Phase): This is when Google’s automated robots, called Googlebot or spiders, discover new or updated pages on the web. Googlebot follows links from pages it already knows to find new pages on your site. The process of discovering a page is called crawling.

   • Analogy: Googlebot is the librarian going out to collect all the new books.

2. Indexing (The Storage and Cataloging Phase): After Googlebot crawls a page, it processes the content (text, images, keywords, structure) and stores this information in its massive database, the Google index. Google uses this information to determine the topic of the page and where it should rank for relevant search queries.

   • Analogy: The librarian brings the books back and meticulously catalogs them, noting the title, author, and subject in the library’s master list.

The critical distinction: A page can be crawled but still not indexed if Google finds technical issues or deems the content low-quality. A lack of indexing means zero visibility.

How To Check If Your Pages Are Properly Indexed

You don't have to guess whether your pages are in the Google index; you can check directly using a few simple methods.

1. The Site Search Operator: The quickest way to check a specific domain is to use the site: operator in Google.

   • Example: Search site:yourdomain.com. The number of results displayed is a rough estimate of the total number of pages Google has indexed for your site. If you search site:yourdomain.com/specific-page and get zero results, that specific page is likely not indexed.

2. Google Search Console (GSC): This is the ultimate tool for monitoring your google indexing status.

   • The URL Inspection Tool: Paste a specific URL into the inspection bar at the top of GSC. It will tell you the current indexing status ("URL is on Google," "URL is not on Google," etc.) and, crucially, why it isn't indexed (e.g., "Crawled - currently not indexed" or "Blocked by 'noindex' tag").

   • The Pages Report: Under the "Indexing" section, the Pages report shows you how many pages are indexed and lists all the reasons why other pages have been excluded.

Common Reasons Why Pages Don’t Get Indexed

If your content isn't appearing in the search results, here are the most common culprits we see at Social Geek:

1. Blocked by robots.txt or noindex Tag: This is the most straightforward problem.

   • Example: Your web developer forgot to remove the Disallow: / command from your robots.txt file after launching, or they left a <meta name="robots" content="noindex"> tag on certain pages. This is a direct command telling Google to avoid indexing the page.

2. Low Quality or Thin Content: If your page has very little unique text, or if the content is highly templated (like filter pages on an e-commerce site), Google may decide it’s not valuable enough to be included in the Google search index.

   • Example: A category page with only a handful of auto-generated product listings and no unique descriptive text.

3. Internal Linking Issues (Orphan Pages): If no other page on your site links to a new page, Googlebot can't find it. This makes the page "orphaned," and Google will rarely crawl or index it.

   • Example: You publish a blog post but forget to link to it from your main blog roll or from any existing, high-authority pages.

4. Crawl Errors and Redirect Chains: Technical errors like broken links (404s), server errors (5xx), or long, confusing redirect chains can stop Googlebot mid-crawl, preventing it from reaching the final page for indexing.

Fixing Indexing Issues Using Free Tools

Fortunately, you can use Google's own free tools to diagnose and fix nearly all indexing problems.

1. Diagnose with Google Search Console (GSC):

   • Use the URL Inspection Tool to verify the specific reason for exclusion.

   • Use the Pages Report to identify the most common error types (e.g., "Discovered - currently not indexed") across your whole site.

2. Verify robots.txt and noindex Status: If GSC reports a block, check your page's HTML source code for the noindex tag. Use a Robots.txt Tester (free online tool) to ensure your file isn't accidentally blocking important sections.

3. Submit to Indexing: Once you've fixed the technical error (e.g., added internal links or removed a noindex tag), go back to the GSC URL Inspection Tool and click the "Request Indexing" button. This manually queues the page for a re-crawl.

4. Use XML Sitemaps: Ensure all the pages you want indexed are listed in your sitemap. Submit the sitemap through GSC. While a sitemap is not a guarantee of indexing, it provides Google with a clear, prioritized list of your content.

How Often Google Updates Its Index

Google's indexing process is continuous, not a scheduled event. Googlebot is constantly crawling the web, and the Google search index is updated in real-time.

• Freshness: High-authority sites (like major news outlets or very active e-commerce platforms in Toronto) that update frequently will see Googlebot visit many times a day. Their new content can be indexed within minutes or hours.

• Smaller Sites: Smaller sites or those that update less frequently might only see Googlebot once a day or even less often. This means it might take a few days or weeks for new pages to appear in the index.

Key takeaway: The healthier and more authoritative your site is, the faster Google will crawl and index your new content. Your goal isn't just to get indexed once; it's to signal such high quality and technical perfection that Google is compelled to return often.

Is Your Hard Work Going Unseen?

The time and money you spend creating great content are completely wasted if Google never puts it in the Google index. Indexing is a technical gatekeeper—and too many businesses fail to unlock it, losing valuable traffic and leads.

If you’re unsure why your pages aren't showing up, or if your Google Search Console reports are full of confusing exclusions, you need expert help.

At Social Geek, we specialize in advanced technical SEO to ensure your website is a high-performing asset for your business.

Don't let technical errors steal your rankings. Contact Social Geek today for a complimentary Technical Indexing Audit and ensure every page you create is visible to your customers.

Contact Us