How to Deal with Soft 404 Errors in Google Search Console

Imagine going to a restaurant that looks busy and open, but when you sit down, the waiter tells you the kitchen is actually closed. The door was open, the lights were on, but there was no food. That frustrating experience is exactly what a Soft 404 error is in the world of SEO.

A Soft 404 is one of the most confusing errors reported in Google Search Console (GSC) because it’s a conflict between what your server is telling Google and what your page content is telling Google. Your server sends a status code (usually a '200 OK') saying the page is fine, but the page content screams that it's empty, broken, or non-existent.

This error is a serious problem. It wastes your crucial crawl budget and signals to Google that your site is providing a poor user experience. At Social Geek, a digital marketing agency in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, we specialize in diagnosing and fixing these technical nightmares to ensure your site is running efficiently. Understanding what is soft 404 errors is the first step to a cleaner, faster website.

What Is a Soft 404?

A Soft 404 is a URL on your website that returns a "200 OK" status code (which means "Success, the page is found") but, in reality, contains little to no unique content, making it appear to Google that the page is not found.

Google's crawlers are smart. They don't just look at the HTTP status code; they also look at the content on the page. If a page returns a 200 status code but displays messages like:

• "Product not found"

• "We are sorry, this page is temporarily unavailable"

• A custom 404-style template with the entire body of content missing

Google will flag it as a Soft 404 in your GSC. Essentially, Google is saying, "Your server says this page is live, but it looks like a dead end to me."

This is a critical distinction because Google will treat this page as a true 404, which means it will eventually de-index the page, causing you to lose any traffic or authority that page may have built up.

Why Google Flags Pages as Soft 404s

Google's primary motivation for flagging Soft 404 errors is to protect its users and maintain the efficiency of its own systems.

1. Wasting Crawl Budget: Every website has a limited crawl budget. When Googlebot spends time and resources crawling a page that returns a 200 status code but offers no value, that time is wasted. If your site has a large number of Soft 404s, Google will reduce the number of pages it crawls on your site, which means your new, important content won't get indexed quickly.

2. Poor User Experience: If a user clicks on a search result expecting a live product page and instead lands on a page with an "Item Not Found" message, that's a negative experience. Google wants to minimize this, and the Soft 404 flag is its way of correcting the issue at its source.

3. Preventing Index Bloat: Google aims to keep its index clean. Pages with no real content add bloat and decrease the quality of search results.

Common Causes and How to Fix Them

Identifying the cause of soft 404 errors is the key to fixing them. Most causes stem from an incorrect server response or an overly aggressive content template.

Cause	Example Scenario	Solution
Out-of-Stock Product Pages	An e-commerce page for a discontinued item displays "This product is no longer available" and returns a 200 OK status.	Fix: Implement a 301 redirect to the most relevant category or new product page if the product is permanently gone. If it's temporary, display an "Out of Stock" message with a re-stock date or email sign-up, and ensure the content provides alternatives to maintain value.
Empty Category Pages	A category page is created with no products yet, showing a message like "Coming Soon!" while returning a 200 OK status.	Fix: Use a noindex tag on the page to tell Google not to index it until it has content. Once the page is filled with products, remove the noindex tag.
Faulty Internal Search	A user performs a site search that yields no results. Your site displays a "No results found" message and returns a 200 OK status.	Fix: Configure your server to return a 404 Not Found status code for all site searches that return zero results.
Thin/Templated Content	A large blog archive page or tag page has very little unique content other than a standard header and footer.	Fix: Either improve the content by adding unique text to the page, or apply a noindex tag if the page has no SEO value.

The fundamental rule for how to fix redirect chains and loops is to ensure that if a page is truly gone, it returns a 404 or 410. If it has moved permanently, it should be a 301. Never let a non-existent page return a 200 OK status.

Differences Between Soft and True 404s

Understanding the difference between 404 and soft 404 error is crucial because it dictates the fix.

Feature	True 404 Error (Hard 404)	Soft 404 Error
HTTP Status Code	404 Not Found or 410 Gone	200 OK (The deceptive code)
Server's Signal	"This page does not exist."	"This page exists."
Google's Interpretation	"The page is gone, I will remove it from the index." (Correct)	"The page is gone, despite the 200 code. I will treat it as a 404." (Correct, but based on content)
Fix Required	Only if the page should exist (e.g., a broken link).	A fundamental change to the server response or content strategy is required.

A true 404 is honest. It's a clear signal to both users and search engines that the URL doesn't exist. A Soft 404 is misleading. It forces Google to analyze the content and override the status code, wasting resources in the process.

Preventing Soft 404s in the Future

Preventing these errors requires a proactive, technical mindset. This is where the expertise of an agency like Social Geek truly shines.

1. Standardize Your 404 Page: Ensure your custom 404 page always returns a true 404 status code (or 410). While you can make the page visually appealing and helpful to the user (e.g., adding a site search bar), the underlying server code must be accurate.

2. Automate Inventory Checks: For e-commerce platforms, set up your system to automatically implement a 301 redirect to the parent category for any product that has been permanently discontinued. Only use a 200 OK status if the page still serves a clear, long-term purpose (like a review or legacy page).

3. Regular GSC Monitoring: Make checking the "Not Found (404)" and "Soft 404" reports in Google Search Console a weekly task. When a new error pops up, address it immediately.

4. Use Log File Analysis: As discussed in our previous guides, use log file analysis to see exactly which status codes Googlebot is seeing. This provides the ultimate layer of verification beyond GSC.

Are Hidden Errors Hurting Your Rankings?

Soft 404 errors are often the first sign of deeper architectural problems on a website. They're silent killers of your crawl budget and can severely impact your organic performance. Fixing them isn't a one-time task; it requires regular, professional technical auditing.

If you're seeing a pile of these confusing errors in your Google Search Console, it's a clear signal that your site needs expert attention. At Social Geek, we specialize in advanced technical SEO to ensure your website is a high-performing asset for your business.

Don't let hidden technical issues continue to waste your crawl budget and hurt your rankings. Contact Social Geek today for a complimentary Technical SEO Audit and let us turn those errors into opportunities.

Contact Us